HOME   ARCHIVE   GALLERY   SHOP   ABOUT US      
 

 
£14MILLION GOVERNMENT WORKING WELL JOB SCHEME MADE ALMOST NO IMPACT IN GREATER MANCHESTER
 

Star date: 12th January 2018

70% OF SALFORD PEOPLE ON JOB SCHEME SAY IT DID NOT IMPROVE EMPLOYABILITY

A £14.4million Government Working Well scheme to help benefit claimants into long-term jobs, piloted in Greater Manchester, "has not increased the chances of individuals moving into work", states an early impact study from the Department for Work and Pensions, published yesterday.

Meanwhile, a separate independent evaluation done for Big Life Enterprises, which got the Salford contract, reported that over 70% of those who gave feedback thought that Working Well did not improve their employability. The GMCA is about to start a £52million extension to the programme.

Full details here...


Greater Manchester Working Well statistics Greater Manchester Working Well Big Life statistics
click image to enlarge

Working Well, or WW, was a five year pilot begun in 2014 by the Government's Department of Work and Pensions (DWP), and run by Salford City Council on behalf of the Greater Manchester Combined Authority (GMCA), with the aim of helping long-term claimants with health conditions into work.

All participants in WW were claimants of Employment and Support Allowance (ESA) in the Work Related Activity Group (WRAG), were deemed as capable of work 'at some point in the future', and had been on the Work Programme but failed to get work.

The idea was that key workers from contracted organisations would help up to five thousand people with problems like health, debts, housing and skills before focusing on employment and then, once a job had been found, provide them with in-work support for at least twelve months.

Two companies were contracted to carry out the programme in Greater Manchester – Big Life, which was supposed to sort Salford, Manchester and Trafford, and Ingeus, which took on the other GM authority areas. And there was huge money at stake for these companies, which were paid on results.

The companies were paid £1,440 per person who joined the pilot scheme; £576 for every person who got work, and £864 for every person who stayed in work for twelve months – a potential of £2,880 per 'client', with scope for five thousand 'clients', giving a total £14.4million potential earning.

Yesterday, the Department of Work and Pensions published an early impact assessment of the pilot, by the Learning and Work Institute, which covered 53% of those referred up to August 2015. It compares those on the Working Well programme and a 'match group'...

"Overall, our analysis of different job outcomes suggests that WW has not increased the chances of individuals moving into work" the authors concluded.

They added that those on WW who did manage to get a job had their time in work lengthened by 4.57 weeks, and did have an impact on being in work for 26 weeks or more...but "The pilot programme was not found to have a statistically significant impact on any periods spent off out-of-work benefits".

Statistics produced by the report show 'no significant' difference between the match group and those on Working Well in eight categories, apart from 'job sustained for 26 weeks', which had a 5% difference (see photo).

Meanwhile, in 2015, Big Life Enterprises, or Big Life, commissioned Scott Dickinson to do an interim evaluation of its delivery of the Working Well programme. While those in Manchester and Trafford thought that the programme was having a positive impact on their employability, in Salford, almost 71% (70.84%) of the 391 people sampled, said that it wasn't improving their chances of employability.

"While clients were generally positive about Working Well's approach, some clients remained uncertain as to their long-term employment prospects" that section of the report concluded.

This month, the Greater Manchester Combined Authority has appointed InWork GM (an 'alliance' of Ingeus and The Growth Company, and including Pathways CIC and Pluss) to deliver a new Working Well programme.

The programme, part of the devolution deal with the DWP and part-funded by the European Social Fund, is costing £52million and hopes to support over 22,000 people across Greater Manchester until 2024... 

"The new Working Well (Work and Health Programme) will support people who are out of work due to poor health and disabilities, and will build on Greater Manchester's successful Working Well programme" states the GMCA "It has been designed to respond to one of Greater Manchester's strategic aims to reduce long term unemployment and help more residents into sustained employment.

"The Working Well (Work and Health Programme) programme will continue to fundamentally change how skills, health and employment services work together across Greater Manchester, by offering a seamless, co-ordinated and sequenced package of support to individuals to help them to address specific barriers and challenges that make it difficult to move forward" it adds.


Read the Government Report - click here

Read the Big Life report - click here

Bob wrote
at 2:28:43 AM on Saturday, January 13, 2018
Bang on Biffo. You're dead right. The only schemes that work,are the skills courses that people actually want to go at. For instance , over the years I have seen A few lads who went on these bricklaying courses. Whilst its true that most of these people had already been in the building game as labourers, and knew a bit, going on these courses helped them brush up a bit and helped them on their way. All these daft schemes they have now are simply a way to discipline the poor unemployed. no wonder they have to employ 3 or 4 bouncers at each dole office to stop people kicking off when they get sanctioned. When I signed on last year for a couple of months, at Churchill way, they arsed me about a bit. One day, as I was leaving the job centre with steam coming out of my ears, I noticed a strong smell of piss coming from the computer room near the front door.One of the jobseekers had pissed on the floor. "Disgusting", I said to one of the bouncers. "Happens all the time mate", said the bouncer. I don't know why but I laughed and went on my way. All this wasted money should be spent on creating new, real jobs. There are plenty of things that need doing that don't get done. All our politicians make a balls of things. The Torys are not capitalists any more, they are moneytryists, and labour are just total wasters of money who have no idea how to spend cash wisely . Look at our lot here. Will we ever learn? I don't think we will.
 
Michael James Felse wrote
at 2:27:57 AM on Saturday, January 13, 2018
These schemes need a drastic overhaul from punishment status into personal ambition courses. Begin by asking the learner what they want to do. Then fit the learning around their own aims. The plan should enable the individual to retain any benefits for twenty months along with a 40% of the training cost as starter payment. This will stimulate new ideas into communities. Catering or Care Worker. Plasterer or Pole-dancer. Gardener or IT Guru. For some the opportunity to go onto other trading and training courses. The importance of individual well-being must be at the core with each getting professional team leadership in nutrition, hygiene, safety and wellness. Salford should sell its assets to put local people in the best position to create personal health, wealth and family happiness. I demand our elected Mayor trebles the Salford skills budget to lead the U.K. into a post Brexit future. He may then be in with a chance of getting my vote.
 
Arnold Rimmer wrote
at 10:08:09 AM on Friday, January 12, 2018
"70% OF SALFORD PEOPLE ON JOB SCHEME SAY IT DID NOT IMPROVE EMPLOYABILITY" - So it did improve it for 30% of them. 30% improvement seems good to me.
 
Biffo wrote
at 8:27:56 AM on Friday, January 12, 2018
None of these organisations that have been set up in order to train the long term unemployed for work ever have good results. They are a waste of tax payers money. For my opinion they are not really expected to produce results, they're really a Government initiative to punish people who are on either JSA or ESA. The way that I see it they're a bit like prison work in Victorian jails, going on the treadmill for ten hours or picking oakum. The philosophy behind it is "have them doing something, and if they don't fully comply then they can be sanctioned."
 
Please enter your comment below:
 
 
 
Salford Star Hoodies
Salford Star contact
Deli Lama
advertisement
 
Contact us
phone: 07957 982960
Facebook       Twitter
 
 
Recent comments
article: PEEL HOLDINGS SALFORD BUILDING SQUATTED BY HOMELESS
Squats conjure up all sorts of images in peoples minds and generally people tend to think of them as scruffy, needle ridden and fi... [more]
article: SALFORD HOMELESSNESS CONFERENCE EXCLUDES HOMELESS AT OVER £325 PER TICKET
What a two faced shirt front.... [more]
article: SALFORD HOMELESSNESS CONFERENCE EXCLUDES HOMELESS AT OVER £325 PER TICKET
The argument that "service users" need to be at a professional conference about homelessness is ridiculous. Whilst I have sympath... [more]
article: ‘NO COMPASSION’ AS MANCHESTER HOMELESS SQUAT EVICTED
Joe is bang on. If you left your dog outside all night in this crap weather the rspca would prosecute you. And rightly so. The thi... [more]
article: ‘NO COMPASSION’ AS MANCHESTER HOMELESS SQUAT EVICTED
Andy burnham as head of GMP should withdraw police support attendance for evictions immediatly. bernard priests vendetta against ... [more]
 
 
 
 
 
Days
Hours
Minutes
Seconds
 
 
 

Donate

Help the Salford Star...

all donations welcome

 
 

More articles...

SALFORD HOMELESSNESS CONFERENCE EXCLUDES HOMELESS AT OVER £325 PER TICKET

Star date: 16th January 2018

SALFORD UNIVERSITY CONFERENCE PROMISES 'UNIQUE INSIGHT INTO CAUSES OF HOMELESSNESS' – WITH NO HOMELESS PEOPLE PRESENT

A University of Salford conference which promises to "provide unique insights into the underlying causes and potential solutions to the homelessness crisis" is charging £325+VAT per ticket, thus excluding not only the homeless but also grass roots housing organisations.

One of the speakers is Salford City Mayor, Paul Dennett, while a panel will ask 'How can we most effectively improve services to vulnerable homeless households and individuals?'...without any 'vulnerable homeless' people there to share their views.

Full details here...

‘NO COMPASSION’ AS MANCHESTER HOMELESS SQUAT EVICTED

Star date: 16th January 2018

BETFRED SQUAT EVICTED AS 17 HOMELESS PEOPLE BACK ON STREETS

Yesterday's early morning eviction of a squat above the BefFred shop opposite Manchester Town Hall has been roundly condemned by housing campaigners, as 17 homeless people were put back on the streets.

Greater Manchester Housing Action stated "shame on whoever it was that made the decision to evict"; while Angela Barratt, of Salford Manchester Street Support, who was volunteering at the squat's night shelter as the eviction happened, told the Salford Star that "There was just no compassion..."

Full details here...

PEEL HOLDINGS SALFORD BUILDING SQUATTED BY HOMELESS

Star date: 15th January 2018

PEEL OFFICES IN ECCLES SQUATTED

As the Manchester squat above BetFred in the city centre was evicted this morning, homeless people in Salford have occupied an office building owned by Peel Holdings near Eccles.

Peel recently received a cheap public money loan of over £8million for its Lightbox apartments in MediaCityUK, where flats cost up to £400,000... "This was our only option" says John who has been homeless for almost five years.

Full details here...

80 YEAR OLD SALFORD PERSON WANTED TO PLANT 80TH ANNIVERSARY TREE IN BUILE HILL PARK

Star date: 14th January 2018

BUILE HILL PARK CELEBRATES 80TH ANNIVERSARY

This month, it's the 80th anniversary of Buile Hill Park since it was inaugurated at its present size. And to celebrate this oak anniversary, the Friends of Buile Hill Park are looking for an 80 year old Salford person, preferably born in January 1938, to help plant a tree.

The Friends are also searching for any living relatives of John Thomas Harrison, who was Chairman of the Parks Committee in 1938.

Full details here...

THOMAS PAINE TO BE CELEBRATED AT SALFORD WORKING CLASS MOVEMENT LIBRARY

Star date: 14th January 2018

A PAINE IN THE DEMOCRACY FARCE

Celebrating Thomas Paine
Saturday 27th January 1pm free
Working Class Movement Library

The Mary Quaile Club and the Working Class Movement Library are to hold a celebration of legendary Brit radical Thomas Paine, whose ideas on democracy and more still hold major relevance two hundred years on. Top tv and film writer Trevor Griffiths will be one of the speakers.

Full details here...

 



written and produced by Salfordians for Salfordians
with attitude and love xxx