HOME   ARCHIVE   GALLERY   SHOP   ABOUT US      
 

 
GOVERNMENT FLOOD REVIEW JUST WAFFLE FOR SALFORD
 

Star date: 9th September 2016

`145 PAGES OF WAFFLE' SAYS SALFORD RIVERS TRUST LEADER

Yesterday the Government finally published its National Flood Resilience Review which was heralded as a `new approach so the nation is better prepared and more resilient to flooding'. But Mike Duddy of the Mersey Basin Rivers Trust has denounced it as "145 pages of waffle...a load of gumf..."

Salford isn't mentioned once in the Review but the other much delayed Greater Manchester report which does include the Salford Flood is due out next week.

Full details here...


Salford Boxing Day 2015 Salford Boxing Day 2015 Salford Boxing Day 2015
Salford Boxing Day 2015 Salford Boxing Day 2015 Salford Boxing Day 2015
Salford Boxing Day 2015 Salford Boxing Day 2015 Salford Boxing Day 2015
National Flood Resilience Review
click image to enlarge

The Government's delayed National Flood Resilience Review was finally published yesterday, promising a `new approach so the nation is better prepared and more resilient to flooding'...

"Last winter we saw just how devastating flooding can be" said Environment Secretary Andrea Leadsom "This review sets out clear actions so we are better prepared to respond quickly in the event of future flooding and can strengthen the nation's flood defences."

The 145 page report promises £12.5million for new temporary defences, such as barriers and high volume pumps, at seven locations around the country... a commitment from utility companies to increase flood protection of things like phone networks and water treatment works...and new ways to assess flood risk.

The Review doesn't mention Salford at all, and Mike Duddy of the Mersey Basin Rivers Trust, has denounced it as "145 pages of waffle...a load of gumf...

"It doesn't say anything or do anything except state that `Yes flooding is a problem and we need to continue to spend money on it'; that is it" he explains "Salford has got two working flood basins but local people have now identified where the weak point is and no-one seems to be doing anything about it. All those houses flooded in the Health Avenue area and this winter, potentially, the same could happen again.

"I have spoken to Salford Council who said they'd been told by the Environment Agency that if there were the likelihood of a flood again in Lower Broughton, it would be possible to erect a temporary flood barrier on top of the existing defence banking" he adds "But for me it would be a much better use of public money, and more peace of mind for local people, if they just raised the flood barrier by three feet which will allow the parks to flood rather than houses. We all know that. It seems to be an easy fix."

Indeed the Government report notes that "Temporary barriers do not provide the same level of protection as permanent defences and typically have failure rates of 20-30%, although these rates of failure can be reduced by good advanced planning...All leak to a certain extent and therefore need to be accompanied by pumps."

One barrier to Lower Broughton flood barriers could be the cost. The Review states that for purchasing, storing and transporting rigid frame barriers for one typical site the estimated cost is £240,000; for sandbags, with protection `considerably lower', it's £60,000, and for `temporary defence' it's between £10,000 and £30,000 per site.

In terms of stopping the flooding in the first place, the Review says nothing, although to be fair, it was about `resilience'. Meanwhile, the other much delayed Greater Manchester flood report is out next week – and residents will be hoping it says more than the National Flood Review which Mike Duddy dismisses as "Whitehall saying nothing"...



• In other non-news, residents are still waiting to see what will happen to the money that was raised for them in various benefits after the Lower Broughton flood. The Salford Star has asked Salford CVS for an update but so far no-one has responded – see previous article click here

A Thought wrote
at 6:24:20 AM on Friday, September 16, 2016
We don't need a 140+ page report to realise errors in the system...I sometimes wonder if the officers in Development talk to their opposite numbers at Environmental Services. We have natural waterways and two canal systems running through our city. Its also in a Valley, meaning any water at the top of the hillsides gather in the area. On occasion the waterways naturally flood. If left alone, the ground would absorb the water and make its way, naturally towards the river system. However, monetary decisions have seen some of the plains these rivers fall on being covered by bricks, mortar and sometimes tarmac...one heavy shower on the now covered flood plain - with their lovely waterside property and those down the hill are crying foul because the rainwater has nowhere else to go but their streets...
 
Alan wrote
at 10:57:41 AM on Saturday, September 10, 2016
I, as a resident of Lower Broughton, will be really interested to see what Tahir Chakotai (adr13263@hotmail.com) means in his post, as many of us are living a life of recovery since Boxing Day and then have to worry that it may be about to happen again. I personally think it's a long-term plan by the people who run us. For example, about 10 years ago the residents on Riverside and Spike Island feared the estate would be demolished. They were in uproar and attended meetings etc. Over the road to us disappeared over the last decade, replaced by new houses, on higher ground, and, because of this, we took their share of water on Boxing Day. We on Riverside/Spike Island are the flood basin. Told back then, circa 2005, by a very senior person after all the protest meetings, that Riversdei and Spike Island were safe for at least another 15 years, I am now concerned. That time is entering its final lap, and. Shock of all shocks we’ve been flooded and almost been so again, and in summer! Is this the next stage of a strategy they are working along? Ten years ago we had men on the estate doing surveys with theodolites machines. I spoke with them, and they said it was being done for a reason, meaning there were plans afoot for the homes on Riverside. The authorities have positioned many residents in a flux of worry, anxiety, as whether any rainfall will see the floods return. Many of my neighbours say they'll be off, if it floods again, which is literally music to developers' ears. Press and distress them out, is their plan. Money must be made. They want the land. It is worth a lot of dosh to developers, worth more to Salix Homes than the rents being collected. Salix will eventually have to call time (rubbing their hands) and report they are no longer able to insure the properties and that many houses’ foundations have been damaged and are therefore no longer safe to live in. For one, I know from 40 years’ experience of living in it, that my home has moved by the floodwater. The floor has sunk in parts (remember, there used to be houses with cellars before us). The fast reaction by Salford Council after last Christmas to bail out the flooded residents with financial help doused residents’ anger back then. But I'm hoping, if it occurs again, the thing will really hit the fan. We have got to wake up. Having just suffered flooding, homes still stinking the whiff of the Irwell, Salford Council showed their class to its poorest residents, inferring on compensation claims of each, they'd carry out random checks (questioning residents' honesty, which was really low). We were told to keep receipts of every item bought and claimed for, wiped out by the flood, as they’d be carrying out random checks in the future! And yet we’ve waited 10 months and counting, to be told why we were flooded. Typical!
 
Muldoon wrote
at 3:02:40 AM on Saturday, September 10, 2016
Well, well, common sence tells me this not a crap report stating the obvious ! Social areas not being mentioned that's right ! The person who did the report prob did it in there hols ? Should try listening and asking the people concerned where to go next as it seems we've been left with our flood problem. Fuming united utilises should be foot a bill as the grids over flood first £60 a month I pay them to do jack shit pay council tax for them to do jack shit ! This broughton flood has been a shock to us all but still NOTHING has been done as of yet ! They need to start work on the river banking and higher it more than the park itself ? That's what should be happening not to be left for it to happen again. Funny how this should be a 50-70 year accurance when we had a further flood warning on 22 august this year ! Not good enough salford council, EA, Manchester council and UU need to step up, not like there doing it for nothing !!!
 
Tahir Chakotai (Independent Housing Advocate) wrote
at 2:01:01 AM on Saturday, September 10, 2016
I don't know if anyone else has noticed, but the banks of the River Irwell seem to have eroded quite dramatically on the Lower Broughton side, within the last 16 months. In my opinion, I have never seen such erosion take place, within such a short space of time. What I would like to say is that there was a document printed within 2013, by the Salford Council, (Salford Council Property Transfer Assessment), which clearly outlined that "The Lower Broughton Area" was at "High Risk" of flooding, and as a result, would be redeveloping certain parts of Lower Broughton. In conclusion, and in my opinion, I do not believe in coincidences, and feel that members of the public, who reside within the Lower Broughton area, should be monitoring the banks of the River Irwell to see what is causing the sudden erosion. In my opinion, I think the residents of Lower Broughton will be surprised at the results.
 
Debbie wrote
at 9:03:31 AM on Friday, September 9, 2016
Told you it would be a load of bollox not even worth a mention! And the Manchester one will be the same recycled crap!
 
wrote
at 9:03:27 AM on Friday, September 9, 2016
What a review... 140+ pages telling us of what we already knew. You got Osborne and Cameron donning their wellies for that photo-op in the Tory-voting communities, Salford received little national coverage. I read somewhere that the savings from Tory cuts to the flood department were wiped out many times over by last winter's flooding and it cost them much more in repairs etc. It cost the taxpayer several times over what it actually saved!
 
Please enter your comment below:
 
 
 
Salford Star Hoodies
Salford Star contact
Deli Lama
advertisement
 
Contact us
phone: 07957 982960
Facebook       Twitter
 
 
Recent comments
article: BBC LOCAL DEMOCRACY REPORTER SHAM AS CONTRACTS HANDED TO MANCHESTER EVENING NEWS PUBLISHER
I look forward to hearing more about this BBC scheme. My first thought is are they moving towards breaking up the current high pai... [more]
article: SALFORD DEATH MAPS SHOW WHERE YOU LIVE DICTATES HOW LONG YOU LIVE
Get the idiotic car width cycle lanes ripped up . Get that Express Leigh Bus lane ripped up . Cars should be able to use these l... [more]
article: CONTROVERSIAL SALFORD CHARITY TO BRING IN INDEPENDENT MEDIATOR
Surely these voices are a "community", a real one and not some sort of "Sim city" version that somebody with no idea of these sort... [more]
article: BBC LOCAL DEMOCRACY REPORTER SHAM AS CONTRACTS HANDED TO MANCHESTER EVENING NEWS PUBLISHER
The scheme looks like a complete nightmare and will be a poisoned chalice for anyone getting involved. You did the right thing ste... [more]
article: BBC LOCAL DEMOCRACY REPORTER SHAM AS CONTRACTS HANDED TO MANCHESTER EVENING NEWS PUBLISHER
I did at one time think that the BBC were the only major organisation that knew the difference between Manchester and Salford. Per... [more]
 
 
 
 
 
Days
Hours
Minutes
Seconds
 
 
 

Donate

Help the Salford Star...

all donations welcome

 
 

More articles...

BBC LOCAL DEMOCRACY REPORTER SHAM AS CONTRACTS HANDED TO MANCHESTER EVENING NEWS PUBLISHER

Star date: 11th December 2017

£8 MILLION BBC NEWS PARTNERSHIP SEES MAINSTREAM COMMERCIAL MEDIA BENEFIT

"This is a major advance...leading to greater public accountability for our local politicians" BBC

The BBC has announced that its new massively funded Local Democracy Reporter scheme is set to benefit the profit-driven mainstream media, with Manchester Evening News publisher, Trinity Mirror, getting six funded reporters in Greater Manchester.

The Salford Star pulled out of the process months ago, with the board telling the BBC "To us it seemed administratively complex and there were doubts about reporter freedom".

Full details here...

SALFORD HAS A LAUGH FOR MALE SUICIDE PREVENTION CAMPAIGN

Star date: 10th December 2017

BIGGEST THREAT TO MEN UNDER 45 IS THEMSELVES

It's A Laugh
Tuesday 12th December 7pm
The Old Pint Pot £5

Two snowmen in a field, one turns to the other and says 'Can you smell carrots?'

Suicide is the biggest killer of men under the age of 45, so Salford University students are holding a fundraising evening of comedy and music, in support of the Campaign Against Living Miserably at The Old Pint Pot on Tuesday, hosted by Amy Gledhill and featuring six top comedians.

Full details here...

SWINTON SQUARE SEES CAROLS, FROZEN PRINCESSES AND SANTA

Star date: 10th December 2017

SWINTON CHRISTMAS IN FULL FLOW

Christmas at Swinton Square
Saturday 16th and Saturday 23rd December free

Swinton Square is well set for Christmas as two special happenings on Saturdays before Christmas feature carols from Salford City Academy, a Frozen family show, a visit from Father Christmas and the chance for adults to win £100 spending money.

Full details here...

TRAFFORD CENTRE ROAD BLOCKED BY BARTON BRIDGE PROTESTERS AGAINST PEEL HOLDINGS ‘MAFIA’

Star date: 9th December 2017

IRLAM AND CADISHEAD PROTESTERS BLOCK ROAD INTO TRAFFORD CENTRE

"People only listen when you cause a bit of havoc, and unfortunately that's what we're going to have to start doing..."

People from Irlam and Cadishead, fed up with the ongoing legal wrangles between Salford City Council, Trafford Council and Peel Holdings that has delayed the opening of the Barton Lifting Bridge, today blocked off the main road into the Trafford Centre in which Peel has a stake.

With banners reading 'Open Our Bridge' and 'Peel Mafia', residents told of the total traffic chaos caused by new road layouts and the still-closed bridge.

Full details here...

CHRISTMAS RABBLE ROUSING WITH BARD COMPANY

Star date: 9th December 2017

TWO SALFORD POETS JOIN ANTI-FESTIVE NIGHT OF ENTERTAINMENT

Christmas Guitar n Verse with Bard Company
Friday 15th December 7pm
The Snug Coffee House, Atherton £2

This Friday sees the rabble-rousing Bard Company play an 'anti-festive' show at The Snug Coffee House in Atherton. Two Salford poets, Gordon Zola and Tony Kinsella, join the quartet for a night of comedy, verse and song, as Ian Leslie discovers...

Full details here...

 



written and produced by Salfordians for Salfordians
with attitude and love xxx