HOME   ARCHIVE   GALLERY   SHOP   ABOUT US      
 

 
CROWN THEATRE ECCLES DEMOLITION OPPOSED BY HISTORIC ENGLAND AND THE VICTORIAN SOCIETY
 

Star date: 2nd August 2016

`UNJUSTIFIED' HERITAGE LOSS IF GRADE ll LISTED SALFORD THEATRE DEMOLISHED

Both The Victorian Society and Historic England have lodged formal opposition with Salford City Council to the proposed demolition of the Grade ll listed Crown Theatre in Eccles, after new plans were submitted last month by developer, Foregate.

Historic England states that the plans represent "substantial harm to this nationally designated heritage asset", while The Victorian Society, furious that it wasn't even consulted by Salford Council, adds that it would be the "total and unjustified loss of a nationally significant building..."

Full details here...


After massive local and political opposition to plans to demolish the Grade ll listed Crown Theatre in Eccles and build a block of unaffordable flats, a planning application by developer, Foregate Ltd, was withdrawn last December.

In July, new plans were submitted which also included the total demolition of the Theatre and the erection of a block of 72 flats, slated by one local resident as a `monstrosity' (see previous Salford Star article – click here).

Now, both The Victorian Society and Historic England have again lodged formal objections to the scheme, following their original opposition to the demolition proposals (see here).

The Crown Theatre (formerly the Lyceum Theatre and Crown Bingo) was built in 1899 and was Grade ll listed as a building of national interest both for its `architectural value and historic interest associated with illustrating social trends at the turn of the century' (for full history see previous Salford Star article – click here).

Historic England states in its objection to Salford City Council that "The current proposal for the total demolition of the building represents substantial harm to this nationally designated heritage asset".

The organisation adds that `substantial harm' to a listed building, according to legislation in the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF), should only be in `exceptional' circumstances and that consent for demolition should be refused `unless it can be demonstrated that the substantial harm is necessary to achieve substantial public benefits that outweigh that harm', or the following reasons apply...

• the nature of the heritage asset prevents all reasonable uses of the site
• no viable use of the heritage asset itself can be found in the medium term through appropriate marketing that will enable its conservation
• conservation by grant-funding or some form of charitable or public ownership is demonstrably not possible
•  the harm or loss is outweighed by the benefit of bringing the site back into use.

The current planning application, states Historic England, "falls notably short of meeting the four tests above". Meanwhile, the `public benefits' arguments don't hold up either as alternative sites for the new flats had not been explored. Neither had there been "a robust viability assessment for the site considering a wide range of options and uses".

The developers argue in their proposal that the interior of building is beyond repair but, while Historic England finds this `regrettable', it adds that "the damage to the interior as a result of neglect has not considerably lessened the overall significance of the building..."

And, rather than just roll over and let the building be demolished, Salford Council should be pro-actively looking to preserve it, states Historic England... "the local planning authority must have special regard to the desirability of preserving the building in line with their statutory duty set out in s.16(2) of the Planning (Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas) Act 1990...

"The local planning authority may wish to satisfy itself that the current state of the building is not a result of deliberate neglect" it adds "...The poor condition of a heritage asset in instances of deliberate neglect should not be taken into account in any decision..."

Historic England concludes: "The case made for the total loss and substantial harm to the nationally designated former Lyceum theatre does not meet the tests of the National Planning Policy Framework. We therefore object to the proposal on heritage grounds, and in line with national policy and legislation..."

Meanwhile, The Victorian Society has also formally objected to the demolition plans and is furious that it wasn't even consulted by Salford Council on the new planning application despite it being a `statutory obligation'...

"It is a matter of concern that the Victorian Society was not notified of these applications by the Council, despite their proposing the total demolition of a listed building" states James Hughes, Senior Conservation Adviser for The Victorian Society in a letter to the Council "Clearly we should have been, and not just as best practice, but as a statutory obligation. May I request that the Council reviews its consultation procedure to ensure that in future we are consulted appropriately and in accordance with legislation."

On the proposals for demolition The Victorian Society endorses the views of Historic England and adds: "We strongly object to these applications, which would entail the total and unjustified loss of a nationally significant building...The demolition of the former Crown Theatre, and the total loss of significance it would entail, is not justified by the information submitted and would conflict with the National Planning Policy. The applications should be refused consent..."



To formally object to the planning application see the Facebook page Object To The Grade ll Listed Crown Theatre Demolition – click here or pick up a form at the Nur Malaysia Cafe at 46 Liverpool Road, Eccles.

There's also an online petition – click here

The Save The Crown Theatre Eccles campaign has also set up a Just Giving page to fundraise £7,000 for an independent Structural Survey and Feasibility Study to go along with its business plan for a new community venue – click here

For further information see the Help Save The Crown Theatre Facebook page

dazza wrote
at 2:31:28 PM on Saturday, August 6, 2016
Where is the vision? Where is the passion? why not invest in the little bit of Salford history we have left, this building could be magnificent again and fulfill its quite right grade 2 status of importance, it would bring much needed jobs to the area and could be multi purpose and adaptable, just make some of the tax dodging property developers pay the taxes that other councils charge and the money would soon be available.
 
Alan Thorpe wrote
at 5:29:39 AM on Thursday, August 4, 2016
The Crown cinema is an eyesore. What would it be used for after refurbishment? Who would pay for the refurbishment? It was always the worst cinema in Eccles and surrounding area. Not even sure there is an architectural style to it.
 
Mary Ferrer wrote
at 1:50:51 AM on Wednesday, August 3, 2016
Why didn't Salford council inform the Victorian society of the proposed plans. The council should be ashamed of the way they have allowed the this building to become rundown. Its a grade 2 listed and the owners have a duty of care and the council have a duty to enforce this. Salford have a bad track record of looking after buildings of heritage interest. This is a chance to make that difference and save this building. I just hope they can find a little bit of passion and say NO to any planning application that wants to knock down buildings of history and are full of character
 
Reg Howard wrote
at 1:50:43 AM on Wednesday, August 3, 2016
Sorry Michael but they are alreasdyb building over graveyards, look where asda is in Swinton, and as usual, Messrs Antrobus and co0 paid no attention to public opinion and just allowed the bodies to be dug up and moved,this, in itself, indicates the contempt that the people of Salford,and their views, are held in by the egotistical people who desecrate the city and call it progress. I call it genocide, and being a sufferer of terminal cancer who has seen the growth and demolition of the city of my birth, I promise that if there is another life after this I will come back and haunt those responsible, Boooo
 
wrote
at 1:50:05 AM on Wednesday, August 3, 2016
Mr Felse is behind the times. He should research what happened to the old Unitarian Church graveyard in Swinton, when the new Asda was built. They did move the bodies though.
 
Michael Jsmes Felse wrote
at 4:30:41 AM on Tuesday, August 2, 2016
The battle moves forward. Let the local people decide, not the property developers. It is time for a people's charter to be given teeth on historic heritage across Salford. Otherwise we will soon see developers also building over local family graveyards.
 
Please enter your comment below:
 
 
 
Brexit Salford
stephensons ad 1
Salford Star Hoodies
Salford Star contact
Deli Lama
advertisement
 
Contact us
phone: 07957 982960
Facebook       Twitter
 
 
Recent comments
article: SALFORD POLIO SUFFERER WAS TRAPPED UPSTAIRS FOR THREE MONTHS AS HOUSING ASSOCIATION WON’T FIT LIFT
When I see all the gold, gems and original art owned by Salford Council then reading the problems forced on local people it to me ... [more]
article: GREATER MANCHESTER PRE-BUDGET RALLY HEARS CALLS TO BRING DOWN TORY GOVERNMENT
I thank the Tory Chsncellor for his budget, but clearly not aimed at reviving the North West to the necessary level of health and ... [more]
article: COURT THROWS OUT SALFORD SCHOOL FINE FOR MUM WHO KEPT SERIOUSLY ILL SON AT HOME
I demand our elected Mayor calls in all our head teachers to an Education Legal Rights Executive meeting to ensure nothing in Salf... [more]
article: COURT THROWS OUT SALFORD SCHOOL FINE FOR MUM WHO KEPT SERIOUSLY ILL SON AT HOME
maybe if she had communicated with the school as well as she has with The Star, she would not have been in such a position... [more]
article: SALFORD POLIO SUFFERER WAS TRAPPED UPSTAIRS FOR THREE MONTHS AS HOUSING ASSOCIATION WON’T FIT LIFT
What used to be the case was this. If special work needed to be done, to enable a disabled person to live in ,or continue to live ... [more]
 
 
 
 
 
Days
Hours
Minutes
Seconds
 
 
 

Donate

Help the Salford Star...

all donations welcome

 
 

More articles...

HUGE COST OF SHUTTING SALFORD DISABLED CHILDREN’S HOME QUESTIONED BY UNISON

Star date: 24th November 2017

SUGGESTED COST OF £250,000 EACH TO MOVE CHILDREN FROM THE GRANGE

Salford City UNISON has written to the Salford Mayor and councillors about the huge cost of moving children from The Grange to placements outside the borough, which it suggests could be as high as £250,000 per child.

Salford Mayor, Paul Dennett, made the decision to shut the city's only home for disabled children but UNISON reckons it would cost more to close the facility than to keep it open. Meanwhile, solicitors representing one of the young people at the Grange are awaiting a judge's decision for a judicial review into the closure.

Full details here...

SALFORD POLIO SUFFERER WAS TRAPPED UPSTAIRS FOR THREE MONTHS AS HOUSING ASSOCIATION WON’T FIT LIFT

Star date: 23rd November 2017  

DISABLED SALIX HOMES TENANT TOLD TO FIND NEW PROPERTY

Salix Homes tenant, Thomas West, has a worsening polio condition that meant the stairlift at his house in Weaste needed alterations but then kept breaking down, leaving him trapped upstairs for three months at one point.

Thomas has been advised by Salford Council that he needs a vertical lift fitted but Salix Homes state it is against their policy and have asked him to consider moving to 'more suitable accommodation'... "I don't want to move" he says, suspecting financial concerns are being put before his needs.

Full details here...

COURT THROWS OUT SALFORD SCHOOL FINE FOR MUM WHO KEPT SERIOUSLY ILL SON AT HOME

Star date: 22nd November 2017

HIS BROTHER HAD ALREADY DIED OF SAME ILLNESS BUT 'HEARTLESS' SCHOOL FINED MUM FOR UNAUTHORISED ABSENCES

"He wasn't going out enjoying himself; he was actually at home trying to breathe..."

A judge at Manchester and Salford Magistrates' Court has thrown out a fine given by Buile Hill Visual Arts College to mum, Nicola Newns, for 'unauthorised absences' of her son, Jacob, despite him suffering from the same serious illness that tragically took the life of his younger brother, Ben, a few years ago.

Court papers showed that the school complained it took them two hours once to contact Nicola – when she was actually in an ambulance with Jacob on the way to A&E; and then couldn't contact her for four days...when she was sat by his bed in intensive care "Praying he gets better".

Full details here...

GREATER MANCHESTER PRE-BUDGET RALLY HEARS CALLS TO BRING DOWN TORY GOVERNMENT

Star date: 21st November 2017

'ARROGANT AND CRUEL' TORY GOVERNMENT GOT TO GO SAY JULIE HESMONDHALGH, TRADE UNIONISTS AND LABOUR COUNCILLORS

Tonight, a Pre-Budget rally on the steps of GMex in Manchester heard constant calls for the 'arrogant and cruel' Tory Government to be brought down.

Speakers at the Manchester People's Assembly rally included trade unionists, Labour Party councillors, the Canon of Manchester Cathedral, plus a message from Julie Hesmondhalgh condemning the Tories' "Unspeakable acts of injustice...against the most vulnerable in our society".

Full details here...

SALFORD SALIX HOMES DISABLED RESIDENT SUICIDE ATTEMPT AS CRIES FOR HELP IGNORED

Star date: 21st November 2017

'HORRIFIED' PARENTS TELL OF SALIX 'TURNING BACK' ON DISABLED SON 

"We can't understand how anyone can let a company do this to a vulnerable person forcing him to try and take his own life..."

The parents of a disabled man living in a Salix Homes flat off Blackfriars Road have written to the Salford City Mayor, Salford MP and local councillors after their son tried to commit suicide in a motorway car park.

The email states that Salix refused to help deal with anti-social behaviour and disability access issues, and "refused to accept that he is even disabled" despite him receiving full PIP... "The fact that his urgent cries for help have been ignored and his landlords have turned their back on him and instructed solicitors rather than provide the help that he urgently needs is horrifying".

Full details and email here...

 



written and produced by Salfordians for Salfordians
with attitude and love xxx