HOME   ARCHIVE   GALLERY   SHOP   ABOUT US      
 

 
GOVERNMENT FORCES LOCAL COUNCILS TO PUBLISH DEVELOPER VIABILITY ASSESSMENTS
 

Star date:  7th August 2018

SALFORD CITY COUNCIL WILL HAVE TO PUBLISH VIABILITY REPORTS

"Any viability assessment should be prepared on the basis that it will be made publicly available..." Government

The Government has published new guidance for local councils to publish viability reports that are regularly used by developers to avoid paying planning contributions and providing affordable housing. The Salford Star estimates that millions of pounds and over 1,000 affordable houses have been lost to the city as a result of this tactic.

Salford Council, thus far, has refused to publish viability assessments, even under the Freedom of Information Act, but the reports will now have to be "transparent and publicly available" states the Government.

Full details here...


Salford viability assessment redacted
click image to enlarge

Back in March*, Prime Minister Theresa May promised to end what she called the "abuse of the 'viability assessment' process", and now the Government has published new guidance for local councils which "supports accountability for communities by enabling them to understand the key inputs to and outcomes of viability assessment".

Viability assessment is a process of assessing whether a scheme is 'financially viable', by determining the costs associated with a development. The 'costs' include everything from the price of actually building the thing, to land value, 'landowner premium', marketing, loan costs and, even more controversially, developer profits which can be as high as 20%.

The Salford Star has shown that a developer can make as much as £24million profit – and still the scheme would be deemed 'unviable'. For years, developers have got their violins out, aided and abetted by a whole industry of agencies that specialise in such matters (including Gary Neville's Zerum), arguing that their profits just wouldn't be high enough if they had to pay Section 106 contributions (for things like roads, parks, education places etc) or provide affordable housing in their developments.

The Salford Star estimates that these viability assessments (plus Salford Council's own developer-friendly SPD policy) has led to around £50million being lost to the city and over one thousand affordable houses.

At almost every planning meeting at Salford Council these 'viability assessments' are dragged out, and planning officers nod them through, without the public being able to view them to make sure developers aren't pulling a fast one.

Salford Council has vigorously defended the privacy of these assessments, firstly refusing to publish them at all, even under the Freedom of Information Act, and lately, when forced to, by redacting everything of any meaning (see photo).

The Government has now published new guidance which hopefully will force Salford Council to finally engage in transparency (albeit too late for the majority of developments)…

"Any viability assessment should follow the government's recommended approach to assessing viability as set out in this National Planning Guidance and be proportionate, simple, transparent and publicly available" the guidance states "Improving transparency of data associated with viability assessment will, over time, improve the data available for future assessment as well as provide more accountability regarding how viability informs decision making...

"Any viability assessment should be prepared on the basis that it will be made publicly available other than in exceptional circumstances" it adds "Even in those circumstances an executive summary should be made publicly available...In circumstances where it is deemed that specific details of an assessment are commercially sensitive, the information should be aggregated in published viability assessments and executive summaries, and included as part of total costs figures.

"As a minimum, the government recommends that the executive summary sets out the gross development value, benchmark land value including landowner premium, costs, as set out in this guidance where applicable, and return to developer" it states "Where a viability assessment is submitted to accompany a planning application, the executive summary should refer back to the viability assessment that informed the plan and summarise what has changed since then. It should also set out the proposed developer contributions and how this compares with policy requirements."

This latter point is really important because it is something the Council stopped doing as soon as the Salford Star exposed it ie what developers should be paying, and what they actually pay. It might not stop developers, 'abusing the viability assessment process' but at least everyone will know how they have avoided paying and the size of their profits.

Unfortunately the Government stopped short of imposing its other proposal which was "'non-negotiable' developer contributions set nationally". This could be rectified locally by Greater Manchester Mayor, Andy Burnham, introducing a set non-negotiable Community Infrastructure Levy for the whole of Greater Manchester. Whether it will happen is something else.

Meanwhile, Salford Council's torturously slow 'consultation' on its own SPD (Supplementary Planning Document) policies which allows developers to pay nothing and provide no affordable housing in certain areas of the city, drags on...and developers are laughing all the way to the bank...

This week, Manchester City Council has launched a consultation around improving transparency in the planning process...

"We want the people of Manchester to have faith in the planning process so they know the decisions being made have been fully scrutinised and where possible, section 106 is being negotiated working with developers on larger developments" says Councillor Angeliki Stogia, Manchester City Council's Executive Member for Environment, Planning and Transport.

"This consultation signals a new approach for developer contributions so that everyone who has an interest in the planning process is clear whether affordable housing contributions will underpin new development in the city" she adds "The move towards publication of viability assessments and affordable housing statements mark the first step in making the process more open and transparent bolstering our clear commitment to affordable housing through the planning process."


In Salford, there's not a word from Salford City Council or Mayor Paul Dennett...


For a full background see previous Salford Star articles...

* Government Admits Abuse of Planning Policies that Have Blighted Salford - click here

Developers Avoid £5million Payments in 2017-18 – click here

Section 106 Delivers Only 16 Affordable Homes in Salford in 2017-18 – click here

Salford Housing Crisis – The Causes – click here

£42million Planning Scandal as Salford Mayor Asks What's Going On – click here

See also the electronic version of Salford Star print issue 10 – the £19million (as it was then) Planning Scandal – click here

Alice wrote
at 16:37:31 on 07 August 2018
The saga of Salford Council and the Developers continues. The Star has done a good job in highlighting the lack of accountability for non payment of planning fees and avoidance of 106 contributions. The details of each Development and the amounts of money lost to the Council have been detailed. At this time, when the public services are being cut, such loss of income is inexcusable. I would also like to draw attention also to the environmental consequences of these highrise offices and apartments ( cubicles) . They do not add to the attractiveness of the city. If you stand outside the Manchester Cathedral and look towards Salford all you see is a panarama of towers, surely blocking out light for the surrounding streets and smaller buildings. Their use is short term since future families will not want this type of accommodation. The highrise accommodation of the 50s proved to be detrimental to healthy living. These buildings were pulled down. The recent Grenville disaster is a sad example of the risks of such buildings. We seem to be repeating the mistake..
 
Paul Gerrard wrote
at 11:28:56 on 07 August 2018
It sounds like even Theresa May is embarrassed at the amount by which developers are ripping off compliant, complicit councils like Salford. Maybe she's worried about the property boom driving sky high rents in places like Manchester / Salford. Whatever. We look forward to reading Salford's 'justification'for the licence to print money south of the Irwell.
 
Please enter your comment below:
 
 
 
Friends of Kersal Moor
Salford Star CD
Salford Star contact
Deli Lama
advertisement
 
Contact us
phone: 07957 982960
Facebook       Twitter
 
 
Recent comments
article: CAMPAIGNERS SAY SALFORD CITY COUNCIL SHOULD BE ASHAMED AS DISABLED CHILDREN’S HOME SHUTS
They can lend or give millions to a rugby club but cannot help Children. They can also donate millions to other unworthy causes th... [more]
article: CAMPAIGNERS SAY SALFORD CITY COUNCIL SHOULD BE ASHAMED AS DISABLED CHILDREN’S HOME SHUTS
They borrowed millions for Greengate, New Baily, Manchester airport and RHS Bridgewater, but not for this essential service? To th... [more]
article: CAMPAIGNERS SAY SALFORD CITY COUNCIL SHOULD BE ASHAMED AS DISABLED CHILDREN’S HOME SHUTS
Bob the regular, why don't you mention eight years of Tory imposed austerity? Is it an oversight or are you showing your "True Blu... [more]
article: CAMPAIGNERS SAY SALFORD CITY COUNCIL SHOULD BE ASHAMED AS DISABLED CHILDREN’S HOME SHUTS
Plenty of money to waste on crap,nothing left for essential statutory duties. Well this is what you all voted for. This is what yo... [more]
article: SALFORD STAR BENEFIT GIG RAISES HUNDREDS OF POUNDS
Great result . Well done to all involved . Was a great night in The Eagle .... [more]
 
 
 
 
 
Days
Hours
Minutes
Seconds
 
 
 

Donate

Help the Salford Star...

all donations welcome

 
 

More articles...

CAMPAIGNERS SAY SALFORD CITY COUNCIL SHOULD BE ASHAMED AS DISABLED CHILDREN’S HOME SHUTS

Star date: 20th November 2018

AFTER LONG BITTER FIGHT, THE GRANGE SHUTS

After years of campaigning and protests, The Grange home for children with severe complex needs finally shut yesterday, after the last resident was shunted out of the city.

"Salford Council should be ashamed of themselves for getting rid of such a valuable facility" says Rebecca Howarth, parent and Save The Grange Again campaigner "We have fought the Council for nearly two years in a bid to keep the care home open but unfortunately we have reached the end of the road."

Full details here...

GRADE II LISTED CROWN THEATRE IN ECCLES TO BE CONVERTED FOR APARTMENTS

Star date: 19th November 2018

SALFORD THEATRE FACADES SAVED BUT BUILDING TO BE ALMOST DEMOLISHED

Planning has now been submitted for the Grade II listed Crown Theatre in Eccles, which proposes to save the facades of the building and some stairs and walls, while demolishing the rest.

The application seeks to convert the site for 82 market apartments, with no affordable housing or Section 106 payments, with a loss to the city of over £200,000 - and with an estimated profit for the developer of over £2million.

Full details here...

SALFORD STAR BENEFIT GIG RAISES HUNDREDS OF POUNDS

Star date: 19th November 2018

EAGLE INN BENEFIT HELPS TO KEEP THE STAR GOING!

Almost £300 was raised last night for the Salford Star at the Eagle Inn benefit gig hosted by Red Rec Records and The Sandells. Four ace bands played free, while friends old and new came to support the city's only - and ailing - independent media.

Full details here...

NATIONAL THEATRE COMES TO FIVE SALFORD SCHOOLS

Star date: 18th November 2018

NATIONAL THEATRE BRINGS THE CURIOUS INCIDENT OF THE DOG IN THE NIGHT TIME

The National Theatre is bringing its award winning play, The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-Time, to five Salford secondary schools this week, which will be accompanied by a learning programme and Q&A with the cast and creative team.

The play will be shown at Harrop Fold, All Hallows, Oasis Academy, St Ambrose Barlow and Moorside.

Full details here...

GIANT SNOWMEN ARRIVE AT SALFORD MEDIACITYUK

Star date: 18th November 2018

WALKING WITH THE SNOWMAN SCULPTURE TRAIL AT MEDIA CITY

From Thursday 22nd November until 6th January, there's going to be a free Walking with The Snowman sculpture trail at Media City, featuring twelve giant sculptures inspired by the song The Twelve Days of Christmas.

There'll also be a collection of smaller snowman sculptures, designed by local young people, displayed inside venues. The event celebrates the 40th anniversary of Raymond Briggs' book The Snowman, and there'll be an auction of the sculptures for Children In Need.

Full details here...

 



written and produced by Salfordians for Salfordians
with attitude and love xxx