HOME   ARCHIVE   GALLERY   SHOP   ABOUT US      
 

 
GOVERNMENT ACCUSED OF DOING NOTHING ON ‘DEATHTRAP’ CLADDING
 

Star date: 7th March 2018

ONLY THREE COUNCIL BLOCKS IN WHOLE COUNTRY BEEN RE-CLAD SINCE GRENFELL – COULD TAKE OVER A YEAR FOR BLOCKS TO BE SAFE

Yesterday, a Parliamentary debate on the fall-out from the Grenfell fire tragedy heard that the Government was doing nothing to sort dangerously cladded blocks..."People are stuck in a building that they describe as a deathtrap" said Labour MP, Steve Reed. No Salford MPs spoke in the debate.

Only three blocks in the whole country owned by councils have been re-clad since Grenfell, as the Minister for Housing, Dominic Raab, said "planning alone can take up to a year". Meanwhile, in Salford, work on some blocks seems to have ground to a halt.

Full details here...


"On average, there is one fire every month linked to this kind of cladding. Eventually, one will not be put out in time..." Steve Reed MP

It received almost no coverage, but yesterday, nine months on from the Grenfell Tower tragedy, there was a major Westminster debate on fire safety and cladding, where the Government was accused of 'doing nothing' to help people in both social and private blocks.

Opening the debate, Steve Reed, Labour MP for Croydon North, said "These people are stuck in a building that they describe as a deathtrap, unable to move and unable to afford the cost of making their homes safe."

He informed that an estimated 800 blocks across the country - 300 council-owned and 500 privately owned - are affected by flammable cladding and added that, post Grenfell, only a 'worrying' three council-owned blocks had been re-clad.

Reed argued that "it is the Government's responsibility to remove the cladding because their flawed regulatory system is what allowed it to go up in the first place".

While tenants in social rent blocks are not having costs passed onto them, those living in private apartments (leaseholders) are currently battling freeholders (who own the actual buildings), developers, managing agents and insurers to avoid massive bills for both temporary fire-safety measures and the costs of replacing the cladding.

A pre-debate briefing from the House of Commons Library reported that costs of £4,000 a week for fire-safety marshals were being passed onto leaseholders; and singled out the Fresh Apartments in Salford where "The Tribunal in this case found that the costs were recoverable based on the wording in the lease agreements."

The Salford Star understands that this ruling is still being challenged, while the costs for fire wardens alone could hit £100,000. The website, Political Scrapbook, recently reported that multi-millionaire, James Tuttiett, who owns the Fresh apartment building via his company E and J Estates, donated £10,000 from his other company Ashcorn Estates Limited to the Tory Party.

"The Government say they are clear that "private sector landlords follow the lead of the social sector and not pass on the costs of essential fire safety works" states Political Scrapbook "So why do the Tories keep taking their money?"

None of Salford's three MPs – Rebecca Long-Bailey, Graham Stringer and Barbara Keeley – spoke in the debate but Manchester Central MP, Lucy Powell, highlighted the Chips building in Ancoats and the Little Alex block...

"The cladding on the Chips building has been deemed non-fire-retardant" she said "That was known at the time, but it was still signed off, and leaseholders are now being charged well over £5,000 each to put it right.

"The cladding on the Little Alex block was within regulations at the time, but following an inspection it has now been deemed to fall outside them" she added "A prohibition notice has been issued; again, it falls on leaseholders to meet the costs, which will be well in excess of £175,000. That is just unacceptable. It is not the leaseholders' fault, yet they are footing the bill."

Lucy Powell added that it wasn't just about the money but also about leaseholders who have 'no right of recourse'...

"Bodies such as first-tier tribunals are frankly toothless; they do not follow through and are very bureaucratic" she explained "Hundreds of people in Manchester and elsewhere are now stuck between a rock and a hard place".

Yet, she added "this is a failure of governance and of regulation. It is our job in Parliament, and the Government's job, to put that right for the people who are now stuck in unsafe buildings that they are unable to sell."

The Government, said Steve Reed, was merely stating that the freeholders had a 'moral responsibility to replace the cladding' but added that it "is not the same as a legal responsibility...

"It could take years for the courts to resolve this and all that time people would be left living in fear" he added "On average, there is one fire every month linked to this kind of cladding. Eventually, one will not be put out in time. Is the Minister really going to do nothing and risk a second Grenfell Tower fire?"

Responding, the Minister for Housing, Dominic Raab, said remediation work was a 'complex process'... "Planning alone can take up to a year" he explained "It is not just a case of ripping down the cladding then deciding what to do next."

Raab added that "We will also consider financial flexibilities for local authorities to fund essential fire safety works to buildings that they own. We have not yet declined a single request."

Ending the debate, Steve Reed questioned the ethics of the Government..."We bailed out the banks when they broke the banking system. Why can we not bail out leaseholders, who are innocent victims of the Government's failed, flawed fire safety regime?"

Back in Salford, it's a mixed picture on cladding replacement for social tenants. In January, Deputy Mayor, John Merry told a meeting of the full Council, re the nine Pendleton Together highrises, that "there will be a start in March, I'm fairly confident, to actually put the stuff on the tower blocks..." (see here)

A message received by the Salford Star this week from a tenant in one of the blocks screamed... "Just got a letter from Pendleton Together about our windows; don't open them as they are faulty; and the nibe a cable might not have been properly secured when it was put in...Pendleton Together, never mind theses 2 items in our flats GET THIS DANGEROUS CLADDING S*** OFF AROUND OUR HOMES AND START TO MAKE US FEEL SAFE!!!"

Meanwhile, the Salford Star understands that City West, which had mainly decorative cladding, has completed work on two blocks, while all other jobs are anticipated to be completed by August. However, work on Salix Homes blocks seems to have stopped altogether, with the company not releasing any information recently.


To watch the full debate on cladding see the Parliament Channel - click here


Other interesting facts to emerge from the Parliamentary debate, related by Steve Reed MP...

"The Grenfell cladding had the equivalent combustibility to 32,000 litres of petrol over the outside of the building.

"The Building Research Establishment's fire testing system is so weak that manufacturers can design the testing rigs that test their own materials, and can then keep quiet about how many tests their materials fail before they eventually get a result they want. Developers, builders and buyers are never told, because the test results are treated as commercially confidential. Conflicts of interest are everywhere in this system.

"The BRE makes money by running tests on flammable materials...up to £40,000 per test that it conducts for manufacturers. As it also drafts the guidance, as an organisation it has a financial interest in permitting the use of combustible materials that it then tests.

"The fire safety tests after Grenfell were carried out by Kingspan, which manufactured part of the materials on Grenfell in the first place..."

Kingspan insulation was also present on Salford blocks (see here)

Phil wrote
at 07:33:29 on 09 March 2018
I love the way that Felsey refuses to engage, to answer questions, but instead just carries on pontificating about everything, waffling on pompously about what he would do. But hang about, isn't that what Salford Labour are always getting pilloried on here for, for not engaging; for not answering questions ... And isn't it mostly The Gang of Three (Felse, Ferrer and O'Neil) who are doing most of the pillorying. You hypocrite Michael. You don't fool anyone, and you will never be Mayor, nor even a lowly Councillor.
 
Phil wrote
at 15:27:45 on 08 March 2018
Felsey, stop jumping on bandwagons. The Council are doing the best that they can. Nobody, not even the "Tutor of The Year" (circa 1994) can expect the Council to move Heaven and Earth in regard to the cladding. They don't have the money, and they are doing their best with what they have. I say this with the authority of one who resides in a tower block in Pendleton. Trust me, we are not all cacking ourselves 24/7 at the unlikely prospect of another Grenfell taking place. The buildings all have round the clock monitoring via security guards walking throughout the building. We all have smoke alarms and, sooner or later the cladding (which is in the process of being replaced) will have been replaced. So stop scaremongering in your wretched attempt at gaining a few more votes. For my opinion you are a populist in the style of Donald Trump, only in your case minus the charisma, sense of humour and billions of dollars. Trust me, your populist approach won't get you anywhere in Salford. This place is a Labour bastion, and it always will be. Finally, because you are always pontificating about what you would do if you were Mayor, and because you are always making "demands" on the comment page of the Salford Star, I ask you once again, what qualifies you to run a City? What experience do you have of running anything and what qualifications do you have? Stop running away and answer me. If you can't, or if you won't, then that simply shows potential voters what a "Tin Man" you are.
 
Felsey wrote
at 11:42:05 on 08 March 2018
Very sorry to all residents at risk. I appeal to Salford Councillors to get the work done now to the highest standards. I pass these towers every day and feel sick to think my Council needs to do more. Come on - impress us with a speedy solution. For God's sake put it right. Nobody must live in fear when there is known a solution. Salford Star has pulled the wool from over our eyes as we all now know solutions are possible. Take cash from Council reserves, do the job, then surcharge builders. Simple as ABC.
 
Please enter your comment below:
 
 
 
Salford Star Hoodies
Salford Star contact
Deli Lama
advertisement
 
Contact us
phone: 07957 982960
Facebook       Twitter
 
 
Recent comments
article: £7MILLION CYCLE AND WALKING ROUTES FOR SALFORD ANNOUNCED
It is good to know we have a bolshevik commisar for cycling. What good advice does he have for people riding near tram tracks?.Per... [more]
article: HARROP FOLD HEAD SLAMS ‘PERSONAL VENDETTA’ OF SALFORD CITY COUNCIL
@Bob - he resigned not made redundant so the council would have paid him a total of £0. For some reason he seems to think he'd b... [more]
article: CLADDING AND WINDOW SAFETY SCARES AT SALFORD BLOCKS
You would think by now, the residents would have had the good sense to work out that however much they complain, there is nothing ... [more]
article: CLADDING AND WINDOW SAFETY SCARES AT SALFORD BLOCKS
As ive said before. If the landlords in Salford are SO BAD. MOVE....... make your life netter. its called personal responsibility.... [more]
article: £7MILLION CYCLE AND WALKING ROUTES FOR SALFORD ANNOUNCED
I thought that's what pavements are for! The designated cycle lanes around higher Broughton and kersal are clearly only there to a... [more]
 
 
 
 
 
Days
Hours
Minutes
Seconds
 
 
 

Donate

Help the Salford Star...

all donations welcome

 
 

More articles...

£7MILLION CYCLE AND WALKING ROUTES FOR SALFORD ANNOUNCED

Star date: 20th September 2018

MONTON, SWINTON AND TRINITY WAY TO GET NEW CYCLE PATHS

Transport for Greater Manchester has announced a plan for £7.1million worth of cycle paths and walkways in Monton, Swinton and Trinity Way, with Salford City Council contributing £1.2million towards the total cost.

"The people of Greater Manchester will soon have a genuine choice in how they travel, ensuring that they and their children have a viable and attractive alternative to the car" says Chris Boardman, Greater Manchester Cycling and Walking Commissioner.

Full details here...

HARROP FOLD HEAD SLAMS ‘PERSONAL VENDETTA’ OF SALFORD CITY COUNCIL

Star date: 19th September 2018

DREW POVEY ACCUSES SALFORD COUNCIL OF 'HEAVY HANDED' 'VENDETTA'

"I'm speaking up for myself but also all the leaders who have been in touch to say the same happened to them #TakeAStand..." Drew Povey

Drew Povey, the Executive Head of Harrop Fold in Little Hulton, has resigned from his post, slamming Salford Council's "heavy handed approach" while investigating 'administrative errors' at the school and accusing it of a "personal vendetta".

In an open letter to the school's governors, Drew Povey writes that he refuses to walk away from the school with a settlement and accept a gagging clause.  So he's gone public...to #TakeAStand.

Full details here...

SALFORD BIG HEALTH DAY FOR ADULTS WITH LEARNING DISABILITIES

Star date: 18th September 2018

BIG HEALTH DAY AT SALFORD CITY FC

Big Health Day
Thursday 20th September 10am-2:45pm free
Salford City FC Moor Lane

This Thursday there's the 9th Annual Big Health Day for adults with learning disabilities, their carers and support staff at Salford City's ground on Moor Lane, with  workshops, activities, information stalls and mystery prizes.  

Full details here...

CLADDING AND WINDOW SAFETY SCARES AT SALFORD BLOCKS

Star date: 18th September 2018

WHY ARE PENDLETON RESIDENTS NOT BEING LISTENED TO?

"The housing provider has lost the good will of residents through their many failings and deafness when it comes to the residents' concerns..."

Windows about to fall out...dodgy cladding...secret safety reports and loads more going on at the Pendleton Together blocks near Salford Precinct.

Here, in the first of a two part feature, Graeme Langton, the suspended but elected chair of Malus Tenants and Residents' Association, writes about multiple problems residents are facing and suggests some solutions for Salford City Council to ponder.

Full details here...

PUBLIC SECTOR WORKERS IN SALFORD WOULD HAVE TO SAVE FOR 17 YEARS FOR A DEPOSIT ON A HOUSE STATES UNISON REPORT

Star date: 17th September 2018

HOME OWNERSHIP JUST A PIPE DREAM FOR NURSES, TEACHING ASSISTANTS AND OTHER PUBLIC SECTOR WORKERS

A new report from public sector trade union, UNISON, concludes that low paid public sector workers like nurses, teaching assistants, PCSOs, cleaners and librarians will almost never be able to afford to own a home.

The shocking report produces figures for Salford that show these workers having to save for 17 years just to get a deposit together for a first time house.

Full details here...

 



written and produced by Salfordians for Salfordians
with attitude and love xxx